The Federal High Court in Abuja has upheld the emergence of former Kogi State Governor, Yahaya Bello, as the All Progressives Congress (APC) candidate for Kogi Central Senatorial District ahead of the May 2026 senatorial primary election.
The court dismissed a legal challenge filed by Momoh Obaro, who disputed Bello’s emergence and claimed that he was the rightful winner of the party’s senatorial primary.
In its judgment delivered on Thursday, Justice Inyang Ekwo ruled that Obaro failed to follow the internal dispute resolution procedures provided by the APC before taking the matter to court.
The judge held that the failure to exhaust the party’s prescribed channels made the suit legally defective.
The case, filed under Suit No. FHC/ABJ/CS/1085/2026, centred on the disagreement over the outcome of the APC senatorial primary election for Kogi Central.
Obaro had approached the court seeking an order declaring him the authentic winner of the exercise.
His challenge questioned the process that produced Bello as the party’s candidate and sought judicial intervention over the disputed primary.
However, Justice Ekwo ruled that the plaintiff did not fulfil the necessary requirements before instituting the action.
The court noted that although Obaro had submitted a petition to the APC Appeal Committee, he failed to take the matter further to the party’s National Working Committee as required under the APC constitution.
According to the judge, approaching the court without completing the available internal dispute resolution process amounted to a violation of a mandatory condition that must be satisfied before such an action can be instituted.
Justice Ekwo maintained that political parties have established procedures for resolving disagreements arising from their internal activities, including disputes over primary elections and the emergence of candidates.
He held that a party member who believes that an election process was conducted improperly must first utilise the remedies provided by the party before seeking judicial intervention, where the law requires such procedures to be exhausted.
Beyond the issue of internal party procedures, the court also examined the documentary evidence presented by Obaro in support of his claims.
The judge identified problems with the documents tendered by the plaintiff, particularly the results allegedly recorded during the senatorial primary across the five local government areas that make up Kogi Central Senatorial District.
Justice Ekwo observed that the documents did not carry the signatures of either the chairman or the secretary of the electoral committee responsible for conducting the primary election.
The court questioned the authenticity of the materials and concluded that they could not be relied upon as credible evidence to establish the plaintiff’s claims.
In explaining the court’s position on the documents, Justice Ekwo stated: “In law, an unsigned document is of no value. The documents are of dubious origin,” the judge said.
The judge consequently ruled that the documentary materials lacked the necessary evidential value to support the reliefs sought by Obaro.
Following its findings on the failure to exhaust internal party remedies and the defects identified in the evidence, the court dismissed the suit for lacking merit.
Justice Ekwo also directed that both parties should bear their respective legal costs.
The ruling represents a legal victory for Bello, whose emergence as the APC senatorial candidate had been challenged by Obaro following the party’s primary election.
With the dismissal of the suit, the Federal High Court declined to recognise Obaro’s claim that he was the rightful winner of the exercise.
The judgment also leaves Bello’s emergence as the APC candidate for Kogi Central undisturbed by the particular challenge brought before the court.
More details later.
