Connect with us

Islamic Jihad News

America’s Absurd Afghan War (Part One)



“The United States fought an impossible war in Afghanistan,” wrote the analysts Daveed Gartenstein-Ross and Jonathan Schanzer from the Foundation for Defense of Democracies (FDD) in 2014. The collected essays they edited in Allies, Adversaries & Enemies: America’s Increasingly Complex Alliances, available online, make for ever-relevant reading years later on the one-year anniversary of American withdrawal from Afghanistan.

The greatest challenge for America in its failed 20-year military campaign the conflict against the Taliban in Afghanistan, the FDD editors wrote, was that Pakistan was America’s “most critical ally and also its most deadly state enemy.” They added, “during the U.S. war in Afghanistan, America gave billions to Pakistan which turned right around and funded insurgent groups that killed Americans.” Analyzing a country often called by Americans a “frenemy,” the pair concluded:

Pakistan’s actions far exceeded the complexity of past U.S. relationships. Pakistan was literally functioning as ally, adversary, and enemy all at once. And the United States never quite figured out how to adjust.  

As the editors and other book contributors extensively detailed, “Pakistan’s military and intelligence services had come to embrace doctrinal reasons to sponsor jihadist militancy” in Afghanistan and South Asia. FDD Senior Fellow and former CIA agent Reuel Marc Gerecht analyzed in his essay contribution:

Before 9/l1, it was gospel in the U.S. government that Pakistan interfered in Afghanistan primarily in pursuit of “strategic depth” in its rivalry with India. Islamabad needed, so the theory went, more space and manpower to use against New Delhi, especially in the disputed region of Kashmir. If India were to invade Pakistan, so the reasoning went, Afghanistan’s territory would allow Pakistan to undertake a strategic retreat, and manpower reserves could be deployed against the invading Indian army.

Pakistani “planners further believed (correctly, it turned out) that Afghanistan’s Islamist groups were more likely to be hostile to India, a non-Muslim power,” added Gartenstein-Ross in his own individual essay. Indeed, after the Taliban took power in war-torn Afghanistan in 1996, the “period of Taliban rule was the only time since Pakistan’s creation that Afghanistan had a strong relationship with Pakistan and an adversarial one with India,” he noted. “Some jihadists groups based in Afghanistan concentrated their militant activities on an issue of great interest to Pakistan: opposing the Indian presence in the disputed Kashmir region,” he added.

FDD Senior Fellow Thomas Joscelyn analyzed how Pakistan’s support of jihadist proxies became prominent in the American-supported Afghan resistance, the mujahedin, to the Soviet Union’s 1979-1989 occupation. “While the United State shipped cash and weaponry to the mujahedin, American spies took a largely hands­off approach when it came to deciding which rebel factions were most worthy of support,” he wrote. On the ground, Pakistan’s Inter-Services Intelligence (ISI) administered the CIA’s covert aid, such that “Pakistan backed the most radical of Afghan insurgent forces,” he observed.

While all mujahedin groups received aid from ISI, the “extremist factions garnered the lion’s share of resources,” Joscelyn noted, 67-73 percent in one estimate. “Among the ISI’s preferred clients were extremists such as Gulbuddin Hekmatyar,” Joscelyn added. “The U.S. government designated Hekmatyar a terrorist in 2003, specifically noting his ties to al-Qaeda.”

ISI’s clients also included Al Qaeda, an alliance that continued when America launched missiles against Afghan terrorist training facilities on August 20, 1998, in retaliation for Al Qaeda’s bombing of America’s East African embassies. “American officials alerted the Pakistani government of the coming missile strikes because the Clinton administration feared that Pakistan might mistake the missiles for a first strike by nuclear-armed India,” Joscelyn noted. Pakistani authorities in turn alerted the targeted camps, allowing Al Qaeda leader Osama bin Laden to escape hours before the missiles hit, although some jihadists and their ISI trainers perished.

Understandably, American policymakers took no chances when they launched a successful special forces mission to kill bin Laden on May 2, 2011, in Abbottabad, Pakistan, without prior notice to Pakistani authorities. Bin Laden “had been living near a cantonment outside of Pakistan’s most prestigious military academy for several years. After the raid, some Pakistani officials could hardly conceal their embarrassment,” Joscelyn observed. FDD founder Clifford D. May correspondingly asked in his chapter,

does anyone seriously believe that no senior Pakistani officials knew that Osama bin Laden—along with three of his wives and a passel of children—had taken up housekeeping in the hill resort of Abbottabad not far from the Pakistani capital of Islamabad?

Bin Laden’s sanctuary was perhaps Pakistan’s most egregious betrayal of the understanding given by Pakistani authorities to American leaders following Al Qaeda’s 9/11 attacks. Gartenstein-Ross explained in his essay:

Pakistan was the main backer of the Taliban, which sheltered al-Qaeda’s leadership, but its geographic proximity to Afghanistan also gave Pakistan the potential to become an important partner in fighting Islamic militancy. The Bush administration addressed this dilemma by dispatching deputy secretary of state Richard Armitage to warn Pakistani president Pervez Musharraf that his country had to decide if it was with America or the terrorists—but, as Musharraf later recounted, “if we chose the terrorists, then we should be prepared to be bombed back to the Stone Age.”

Gartenstein-Ross found it “unsurprising that Musharraf’s reversal of support for jihadist groups didn’t hold up. The factors driving Pakistan’s support for violent Islamist group in Afghanistan simply represented too tangled a web.” In the end, Pakistan “would become the most prominent sponsor of the insurgency in Afghanistan” against the American-led coalition fighting Al Qaeda and their Taliban allies. Yet the coalition’s “decision to route supplies through Pakistan also created such a dangerous dependency on Pakistan’s help that the United States fettered its own ability to respond to Pakistan’s support for militants,” he wrote. The result he termed a “Handcuffed Superpower.”

The FDD analysis confirms why any American objective in Afghanistan beyond devastating Al Qaeda to include a decisive defeat of the Taliban was, in the 2012 description of Jihad Watch director Robert Spencer, a “fool’s errand.” Yet Americans and their allies continued to expend blood and treasure in Afghanistan until 2021, even as FDD analysts gloomily foresaw a foregone, ignominious conclusion in region often called the “graveyard of empires.” The problems and dangers of the Islamic world are too deep-seated for any foreign intervention to solve, as the concluding article in this series will examine.


News3 mins ago

President Tinubu Enacts Game-Changing Electricity Bill in Nigeria

Entertainment13 mins ago

Video: “Jay Z Will Be Disappointed Hearing You Say Ewo Ooo” Fans Tease Charles Okocha As His Local Accent Creeps In During Link Up With Hilda

Naija Music14 mins ago

MP3: DJ Maff – Trending Gospel Mix

News15 mins ago

President Tinubu Takes Swift Action: Suspends Central Bank Governor Godwin Emefiele

Entertainment15 mins ago

B-Red recounts how he and Davido sold 20 TVs from his father’s house to raise money (Video)

Entertainment17 mins ago

Princess Chidimma Reacts As Actress Chioma Nwaoha Shares New Photo Of Herself In Bikini

News19 mins ago

Davido and I stole 20 TVs from his father’s house – B-Red recounts

News24 mins ago

Olamide agrees that Wizkid is bigger than every artiste

Entertainment25 mins ago

Video: “Back to secure her throne” – Ned Nwoko’s fourth wife Laila Charani boos up with billionaire husband, video goes viral

Entertainment27 mins ago

IK Ogbonna, Linda Osifo, Nancy Isime, Others react as Ini Edo shares new photo

News29 mins ago

Fight breaks out in family after man won N152 million lottery (Video)

Entertainment29 mins ago

Portable continues to diss Small Doctor, slams him for bad mouthing Olamide (Video)

News31 mins ago

What’s The Difference Between El-Rufai’s Action & The Offence That Nnamdi Kalu Is Accused Of – Clarke

News43 mins ago

DSS Finally Arrests CBN Gov Emefiele After Failed Attempts

Naija Music49 mins ago

MP3: Dopestiks – Molly

News2 days ago

BREAKING: President Bola Tinubu Lifts Ban On Bitcoin, Other Cryptocurrencies

News3 days ago

BREAKING: Jubilation As Government Increases Minimum Wage To N40000, Reduces working days to 3 per week

News2 days ago

Enchanting Ankara styles to recreate this month

News2 days ago

BREAKING: President Bola Tinubu Signs Bill Raising Judges Retirement Age Into Law

Entertainment3 days ago

Motorcyclists in Cameroon protest against Tinubu over removal of fuel subsidy

Enews1 day ago


News2 days ago

JUST IN: President Bola Ahmed Tinubu Finally Reveals Preferred Choice For Next Senate President

Entertainment3 days ago

Video: “When you’re not doing rituals” – Singer BNXN gushes over Burnaboy expensive automobile in new video [Watch]

Entertainment2 days ago

Video: Bobrisky Sleeps with Me Every Night, I Left Because I Can’t Cope With His Demands – Former PA, Oye Kyme

Entertainment19 hours ago

Umar Namadi Bio: Early Life, Career, Wife and Net Worth

Entertainment11 hours ago

“She don spoil the remaining table” – Rita Edochie exposes details of Yul and Judy Austin’s introduction

News10 hours ago

GODWIN EMEFIELE: How #CBN Reacted After The Suspension Of CBN Governor

Entertainment1 day ago

Reactions as reality tv star Bella shares stunning photos of herself on Ig.

Entertainment1 day ago

Video: “Adelekes, please take your child to rehab” Heidi Korth Cries Out as She Shares Messy Chats with Sina Rambo

Entertainment2 days ago

Video: Video Of Young Boy Behind The Local Flute In Kcee’s Hit Song, Ojapiano, Surfaced, Gets Fans Talking