A retired Justice of the Court of Appeal, Oludotun Adefope-Okojie, has warned Nigerian courts against declaring candidates who lost elections as winners through judicial pronouncements, insisting that disputed electoral mandates should be returned to voters whenever the rightful winner cannot be established.
Adefope-Okojie gave the warning while delivering the 2026 GAVEL International Annual Lecture, themed, “Electoral Process in Nigeria: Managing the Boundaries of Judicial Intervention.”
She argued that the judiciary must not take over the responsibility of voters by determining who should occupy an elective position, stressing that courts should not become an alternative route for politicians who failed to secure victory at the polls.
“It is not the duty of the Courts to award seats,” she declared.
The retired jurist maintained that where a candidate is disqualified or serious electoral irregularities make it impossible to determine the actual winner, the appropriate remedy should generally be a fresh election rather than declaring the runner-up elected.
She expressed concern over the growing dependence of Nigerian politicians on litigation to determine electoral victories, revealing that 1,209 petitions were filed out of 1,280 contested seats following the 2023 general elections.
According to her, the figure represents 94.5 petitions per 100 contested seats, compared with 6.5 in Kenya’s 2022 elections and 5.8 in Ghana’s 2020 elections.
She noted that despite the large number of petitions in Nigeria, only 103 were successful, raising concerns about public confidence in the electoral process.
Adefope-Okojie attributed the development partly to alleged impunity within political parties, including flawed congresses, imposition of candidates and unlawful replacement of duly nominated aspirants.
Citing the Supreme Court’s April 30, 2026 ruling in PDP v. Sule Lamido, she urged judges to intervene in internal party disputes where political parties violate their constitutions and relevant electoral laws.
She also criticised evidential requirements that compel election petitioners to produce polling-unit officials and witnesses before relying on certified electoral documents, arguing that such requirements make it difficult to establish cases of electoral manipulation.
With the 2027 general elections approaching, she urged judges and election tribunal members to remain impartial and uphold the sovereignty of the electorate.
“The Constitution places sovereignty in the people and makes the Courts the guardians of that sovereignty, not its holders,” she said.
Also speaking, human rights lawyer, Femi Falana (SAN), called on the National Assembly and judiciary to reform Nigeria’s electoral litigation framework to prevent election appeals from overwhelming the Supreme Court.
Falana advocated a return to the previous legal arrangement for determining governorship election disputes, arguing that the reform process had repeatedly stalled since 2011.
He also faulted what he described as unjustified differences in the appeal procedures for presidential and legislative election petitions.
Referring to controversial judgments in Kogi and Zamfara states, Falana lamented instances where judicial decisions allegedly displaced the choices made by voters by installing candidates who lost at the polls.
Earlier, GAVEL International Publisher, Mustapha Ogunsakin, commended Adefope-Okojie for her contributions to the judiciary.
Ogunsakin recalled her leadership of a 2005 Lagos State tribunal established to investigate security breaches at the Ikeja High Court.
He said her courage, intellectual rigour and timely submission of the tribunal’s report, which was commended by then Lagos State Governor, Bola Tinubu, helped establish a lasting framework for court security across the state.
