Headlines

Death of 33 detainees exposes lapses in Criminal Justice Administration – SAN

By Safia Abdulrahman/Ebere Agozie

Senior Advocate of Nigeria, Habeeb Oredola, says deaths of 33 detainees, including 14 minors, at the Nigeria Security and Civil Defence Corps (NSCDC) facility in Niger have exposed lapses in justice administration

Oredola said this in his paper presentation at the 8th Annual Criminal Law Review Conference organised by the Rule of Law Development Foundation in Abuja.

According to him, the deaths in NSCDC facility in Minna, Niger resulted from severe overcrowding, unlawful detention conditions, failure in the duty of care and disregard for repeated distress warnings.

He said the incident raised serious questions about the protection of the rights of suspects and the responsibility of law enforcement agencies to safeguard persons in their custody.

Oredola noted that the detainees had not been convicted of any offence and were therefore entitled to the constitutional presumption of innocence.

He stressed that the power to arrest and detain citizens was subject to constitutional safeguards, statutory provisions and judicial oversight.

He said the incident was particularly disturbing because existing laws already provided safeguards against unlawful detention and inhumane treatment.

He said the failure to respect those legal obligations contributed to the tragedy and made accountability difficult.

Oredola also highlighted concerns surrounding the circumstances of the operation, including the alleged absence of an approved operational order, failure to consult relevant mining authorities and the detention of suspects from mining sites reportedly covered by valid licences.

He said the incident demonstrated the need for better coordination among law enforcement agencies and relevant regulatory authorities.

The SAN emphasised that the effectiveness of the criminal justice system should not be measured only by arrests, prosecutions and convictions but also by how the state treats persons in its custody.

He called for institutional reforms to prevent such incidents and ensure that officers responsible for violations were held accountable.

He, therefore, called for stronger accountability in Nigeria’s criminal justice system, saying the country suffers not from a shortage of laws but from failure to enforce them. (NAN)

EPA/IAA

=======

Edited by Isaac Aregbesola

A Senior Advocate of Nigeria (SAN), Habeeb Oredola said the recent deaths of the 33 detainees, including 14 minors, at the Nigeria Security and Civil Defence Corps (NSCDC) facility in Minna, Niger has exposed serious lapses in the administration of criminal justice in Nigeria.

Oredola made the call in his paper presentation, at the 8th Annual Criminal Law Review Conference organised by the Rule of Law Development Foundation in Abuja.

According to him, the deaths resulted from severe overcrowding, unlawful detention conditions, failure of duty of care and disregard for repeated distress warnings.

He said the incident raised serious questions about the protection of the rights of suspects and the responsibility of law enforcement agencies to safeguard persons in their custody.

Oredola noted that the detainees had not been convicted of any offence and were therefore entitled to the constitutional presumption of innocence.

He stressed that the power to arrest and detain citizens was subject to constitutional safeguards, statutory provisions and judicial oversight.

He said the incident was particularly disturbing because existing laws already provided safeguards against unlawful detention and inhumane treatment.

He said the failure to respect those legal obligations contributed to the tragedy and made accountability difficult.

Oredola also highlighted concerns surrounding the circumstances of the operation, including the alleged absence of an approved operational order, failure to consult relevant mining authorities and the detention of suspects from mining sites reportedly covered by valid licences.

He said the incident demonstrated the need for better coordination among law enforcement agencies and relevant regulatory authorities.

The SAN emphasised that the effectiveness of the criminal justice system should not be measured only by arrests, prosecutions and convictions but also by how the state treats persons in its custody.

He called for institutional reforms to prevent such incidents and ensure that officers responsible for violations were held accountable.

He, therefore, called for stronger accountability in Nigeria’s criminal justice system, saying the country suffers not from a shortage of laws but from failure to enforce them. (NAN)